Understanding Diamond Clarity Grades

Understanding Diamond Clarity Grades: A Complete Guide to Diamond Quality

Diamond clarity is one of the essential 4Cs that determines the overall quality of a stone, beauty, and value. While cut shapes determine how a diamond reflects light and carat determines size, clarity focuses on the gemstone's purity. How free it is from internal inclusions or external blemishes. 

From the 4Cs of diamond, the diamond’s clarity directly influences its brilliance, sparkle, and even rarity, which in turn affects pricing and long-term value. Whether you’re a collector, an investor, or purchasing a piece for personal enjoyment, understanding clarity grades is key to making informed decisions. 

From flawless diamonds that are almost impossible to find to more affordable, eye-clean stones that appear perfect to the naked eye, clarity plays a critical role in ensuring you get the best combination of beauty and value. So, without any further ado, let's move towards understanding the diamond clarity grades.

What Is Diamond Clarity?

Diamond clarity refers to the absence of internal imperfections, known as inclusions, and external blemishes on a gemstone. In simple terms, it measures how clean or pure a diamond appears when examined under magnification.

Inclusions can include tiny crystals, clouds, or feathers inside the stone, while blemishes are surface marks like scratches or pits. The fewer these imperfections, the higher the clarity grades, which often correlates with rarity and value. 

While some inclusions are microscopic and invisible to the naked eye, they can influence how light passes through the diamond, affecting its sparkle and brilliance. Understanding clarity helps buyers identify stones that are not only visually stunning but also resilient and long-lasting, making it a crucial factor in selecting the right diamond.

Why Clarity Matters in Diamonds

Diamond clarity grades play a crucial role in determining a stone's overall beauty, performance, and value. Here is why it matters:

  • Affects Sparkle and Brilliance: Inclusions and blemishes can interfere with how light travels through a diamond. Higher clarity allows light to reflect freely, enhancing sparkle and creating a more dazzling appearance.

  • Impacts Visual Appeal: Minor imperfections may alter a diamond's look under magnification. Clean diamonds appear more flawless, making them highly desirable for both collectors and everyday wear. Many buyers may not notice microscopic inclusions with the naked eye, but under careful inspection, these differences can distinguish a good diamond from an exceptional one.

  • Influences Rarity and Value: Flawless or internally flawless diamonds are scarce, and this scarcity drives their premium pricing. Stones with fewer imperfections are often considered more prestigious and investment-worthy, attracting collectors who seek unique gems.

  • Investment Potential: Diamonds with higher clarity tend to retain or appreciate in value over time. Rare, high-clarity stones attract investors looking for both beauty and financial security, making clarity not only a visual feature but also a strategic consideration for long-term asset planning.

How Diamond Clarity Is Graded

Diamond clarity is assessed through a careful, multi-step process by trained gemologists to determine the presence of inclusions and blemishes. Understanding this process helps buyers appreciate how clarity affects value and beauty.

Step 1: Initial Inspection

The diamond is first examined with the naked eye to get a general sense of its surface quality and visible inclusions. While most imperfections are too minor to be seen without magnification, this step provides an overview of the diamond’s overall cleanliness.

Step 2: Magnification Examination

Next, experts use a 10x magnification loupe or microscope, the industry standard, to carefully inspect the diamond for internal inclusions and external blemishes. This is where subtle features, like tiny crystals, feathers, or clouds, become visible.

Step 3: Identifying and Categorizing Imperfections

Gemologists identify the type, size, location, and quantity of inclusions and blemishes. Each factor is carefully noted because it influences the visibility of imperfections and their impact on the diamond's brilliance.

Step 4: Comparing Against Standards

The diamond is then compared against established grading standards, such as the GIA clarity scale, to determine its exact clarity grade. Experts assess whether the imperfections are minor or significant, which directly affects the stone's rarity and value.

Step 5: Final Clarity Assignment

After thorough inspection and evaluation, a clarity grade is assigned, ranging from Flawless (FL) to Included (I1, I2, I3). This grade provides buyers with a trusted measure of the diamond's purity, rarity, and overall quality, helping them make an informed purchasing decision.

The GIA Clarity Scale Explained

The GIA clarity scale is the industry standard for grading diamonds, ranging from flawless stones to those with visible inclusions. Understanding each grade helps buyers choose diamonds that balance beauty, rarity, and value.

  • Flawless (FL): These diamonds have no internal inclusions or external blemishes under 10x magnification. They are sporadic and command very high premiums. Flawless diamonds are considered the ultimate standard of purity and are highly prized by collectors and investors.

  • Internally Flawless (IF): IF diamonds contain no internal inclusions, but may have minor surface blemishes. They are almost as rare as flawless diamonds and still carry significant value, though slightly less expensive than FL stones.

  • Very Very Slightly Included (VVS1, VVS2): These diamonds have minute inclusions that are extremely difficult to see even under 10x magnification. VVS diamonds are very rare and highly sought after, providing near-perfect visual appeal while offering a more accessible price point than FL or IF stones.

  • Very Slightly Included (VS1, VS2): VS diamonds contain minor inclusions that are challenging to detect under magnification. They offer a strong balance of rarity, beauty, and affordability, making them a popular choice for engagement rings and fine jewelry.

  • Slightly Included (SI1, SI2): Then come SI diamonds, which have noticeable inclusions under magnification, but many are eye-clean, meaning imperfections are not visible to the naked eye. They provide excellent value and often allow buyers to purchase larger or higher-color diamonds at a lower cost.

  • Included (I1, I2, I3): These diamonds have visible inclusions that can affect brilliance and durability. While they are more affordable, the imperfections are often noticeable, making them less desirable for high-end jewelry, though suitable for budget-conscious buyers or specific casual settings.

Eye-Clean Diamonds: The Buyer's Perspective

Many buyers are surprised to learn that diamonds graded SI1, SI2, or even some VS2 stones can appear entirely flawless to the naked eye. These diamonds are considered eye-clean, meaning that any inclusions are too small or strategically positioned to be visible without magnification. 

For most diamond jewelry applications, especially in well-cut stones, eye-clean diamonds offer the same visual impact as higher-graded stones at a more accessible price. This makes them an excellent option for buyers who want a sparkling, beautiful diamond without paying a premium for flawless clarity.

Understanding which diamonds are eye-clean allows buyers to make informed decisions, balancing clarity, carat, and budget while still achieving a stunning appearance in diamond rings, necklaces, and other fine jewelry pieces.

The Relationship Between Clarity and Value

Clarity has a significant impact on a diamond's rarity, beauty, and price, but it is important to understand that the highest clarity does not always equal the best value. Flawless (FL) and Internally Flawless (IF) diamonds are very rare, and this scarcity commands top-tier prices per carat, appealing mainly to collectors and investors. For example, the 12.03-carat Blue Moon of Josephine fetched $48.4 million at Sotheby’s in 2015, setting a record for price per carat. 

On the other hand, diamonds in the VS1, VS2, or even SI1 ranges can often be eye-clean, meaning inclusions are invisible to the naked eye. These diamonds provide stunning brilliance and aesthetic appeal at a fraction of the cost of FL or IF stones.

For most buyers, balancing clarity with 4Cs diamond factors like cut, color, and carat is the key to maximizing value. Choosing an eye-clean diamond allows you to enjoy exceptional beauty while avoiding the premium associated with perfection that may not even be noticeable in daily wear. By understanding this balance, buyers can make informed decisions that combine visual appeal, rarity, and cost-effectiveness.

Choosing the Right Clarity Grade

When selecting a diamond, clarity is an important consideration, but it should not overshadow other factors like cut, color, and carat. The key is finding a balance between beauty, rarity, and budget.

Here are some practical tips for choosing the right clarity grade:

  • Prioritize Eye-Clean Stones: Look for diamonds where inclusions are not visible without magnification. These stones offer the sparkle and brilliance of higher-graded diamonds without the premium price. Eye-clean diamonds allow buyers to enjoy the visual beauty and fire of the stone while avoiding unnecessary spending on perfection that may not even be noticed in daily wear.

  • Balance with Other 4Cs: A well-cut diamond with slightly lower clarity often looks more brilliant than a higher-clarity stone with a poor cut. Cut directly influences how light travels and reflects inside the diamond, so prioritizing a better cut can make a VS or SI diamond look just as stunning as a flawless stone, often at a fraction of the cost.

  • Consider Jewelry Setting: Certain inclusions can be hidden or minimized by clever jewelry settings, such as prongs, bezels, or halos. This means that a slightly lower clarity diamond can appear flawless once set, giving buyers more flexibility in choosing a stone that fits their budget while still looking visually perfect in rings, earrings, or pendants.

  • Match Your Budget and Goals: Clarify whether your priority is rarity, size, or visual perfection. Eye-clean VS or SI diamonds often offer the best combination of aesthetics, rarity, and value. By carefully weighing these factors, buyers can make informed decisions, ensuring their diamond meets both personal preferences and long-term investment considerations.

By keeping these tips in mind, buyers can confidently select a diamond that looks stunning, feels rare, and delivers long-term value, without overpaying for perfection that may be invisible to the naked eye.

Diamond Clarity in Different Shapes

The visibility of inclusions can vary significantly depending on the shape of the diamond and cut. Specific cuts are more forgiving, while others highlight every imperfection, making clarity a critical consideration.

  • Brilliant Cuts (e.g., Round, Oval, Cushion): These cuts are designed with multiple facets that reflect light in many directions, creating intense sparkle and brilliance. The complex faceting tends to mask minor inclusions, making VS and SI diamonds appear eye-clean.

  • Step Cuts (e.g., Emerald, Asscher): Step-cut diamonds feature large, open facets arranged in parallel lines. For emerald or Asscher cuts, buyers often prefer higher clarity grades, such as VS or VVS, to ensure that internal flaws do not distract from the diamond's clarity and overall beauty.

  • Other Fancy Shapes (e.g., Pear, Marquise, Princess): These shapes fall somewhere in between. Their faceting patterns can either conceal or reveal inclusions depending on size and location. Careful inspection and selection are necessary to ensure that the diamond looks clean to the naked eye.

By considering both the cut and clarity together, you can select a diamond that maximizes brilliance while minimizing visible imperfections, achieving the perfect balance of beauty and value.

Clarity and Carat Weight

As a diamond’s carat weight increases, its clarity becomes an even more critical factor. Larger diamonds have more surface area and internal volume, which makes inclusions and blemishes more noticeable. Even minor imperfections that are barely visible in a smaller stone can stand out in a larger gem, potentially affecting both its beauty and value.

For diamonds above 1.5–2 carats, buyers often prefer higher clarity grades, such as VS or VVS, to ensure the stone appears flawless to the naked eye.

However, there are ways to balance clarity and budget. Eye-clean SI1 or SI2 diamonds, with inclusions positioned away from the center, can still look stunning while being significantly more affordable than higher-clarity stones. 

Common Myths About Diamond Clarity

There are many misconceptions surrounding diamond clarity that can confuse buyers and lead to unnecessary spending. One common myth is that only flawless or internally flawless diamonds are worth buying. But, in reality, many diamonds in the VS or SI ranges are eye-clean, appearing completely flawless to the naked eye while costing significantly less than FL or IF stones.

Another misconception is that higher clarity automatically means better sparkle. While clarity affects purity, a diamond’s cut has a far greater impact on brilliance and fire, meaning a well-cut SI diamond can appear more dazzling than a poorly cut VVS stone. 

Some buyers also mistakenly believe that inclusions always weaken a diamond. While severe inclusions in I-grade stones can affect durability, most minor inclusions in higher-grade diamonds do not compromise the stone’s strength or longevity.

Certification and Diamond Clarity

Certification from reputable laboratories like GIA (Gemological Institute of America) and IGI (International Gemological Institute) plays a vital role in ensuring trust and accuracy in diamond clarity. These certifications provide an independent, expert assessment of internal inclusions and external blemishes of a diamond, assigning a precise clarity grade based on standardized industry criteria.

By relying on certified reports, buyers can confidently verify a diamond’s quality, rarity, and value, knowing that the assessment is objective and recognized worldwide. For rare or high-clarity diamonds, certification is vital, as even minor differences in grading can significantly affect pricing and resale value. 

These reports often include detailed diagrams and descriptions of inclusions, helping buyers understand the stone’s unique characteristics. Certification not only protects buyers from overpaying or misrepresentation but also provides peace of mind, ensuring that the diamond’s clarity grade is accurately documented and globally recognized.

Tips for Getting the Best Value from Clarity

Buying a diamond with the right clarity does not have to break the bank. Here are practical strategies to maximize value while ensuring beauty:

  • Buy Eye-Clean Diamonds: Focus on stones where inclusions are not visible to the naked eye. Eye-clean SI or VS diamonds often appear flawless in jewelry, allowing buyers to enjoy a stunning look without paying a premium for FL or IF grades.

  • Prioritize Cut Over High Clarity: A diamond’s cut has a greater impact on brilliance and sparkle than its clarity alone. Choosing a well-cut VS or SI diamond can result in a more dazzling stone than a poorly cut higher-clarity diamond, ensuring beauty and visual impact.

  • Check Diamond Shape and Size: Larger diamonds or step-cut shapes like emeralds may require higher clarity grades, while brilliant cuts can conceal minor imperfections. Understanding how clarity interacts with shape helps buyers select a stone that looks clean and radiant.

  • Use Certification for Verification: Always rely on GIA or IGI-certified diamonds to ensure the clarity grade is accurate. Certification provides a trusted reference for inclusions and overall quality, giving buyers confidence in their purchase.

By following these strategies, buyers can maximize sparkle, maintain value, and enjoy a visually flawless diamond without overspending.

Leon Diamond’s Approach to Diamond Clarity

At Leon Diamond, we understand that clarity is more than just a grade; it is a key factor in a diamond’s beauty, rarity, and long-term value. Our team of experts carefully evaluates each stone to ensure that it meets strict clarity standards while offering the best balance with cut, color, and carat. We prioritize eye-clean diamonds in the SI and VS ranges, helping buyers find stunning stones that look flawless without paying the premium for perfection.

Every diamond we offer comes with GIA or IGI certification, guaranteeing that clarity grades are accurate and globally recognized. By combining expert knowledge, certified grading, and attention to detail, Leon Diamond helps buyers make informed decisions, selecting diamonds that are both beautiful and a smart investment for the future.

Unlock the True Beauty of Diamonds with the Right Clarity

Understanding how inclusions and blemishes affect a stone helps buyers make smart, informed decisions that balance beauty, quality, and cost. Eye-clean VS and SI diamonds often deliver exceptional sparkle while offering excellent value, proving that perfection isn’t always necessary to achieve a stunning look.

Explore Leon Diamond’s collection today to discover expertly graded, certified diamonds that combine clarity, elegance, and value, ensuring that every purchase is as brilliant as the stone itself.

Frequently Asked Questions

What clarity grade is best for value?

Yes, VS2 or SI1 diamonds often give the best balance of price and eye-clean appearance. These grades allow buyers to enjoy a visually flawless stone without paying the premium associated with higher clarity diamonds.

Are flawless diamonds worth the price?

No, for most buyers, eye-clean stones look identical to the naked eye and are more cost-effective. Flawless diamonds are extremely rare and expensive, making them better suited for collectors or investors rather than everyday jewelry purchases.

Does a diamond shape affect clarity needs?

Yes, step cuts like emeralds require higher clarity grades than brilliant cuts because inclusions are more visible. In contrast, brilliant cuts with multiple facets can hide minor imperfections, allowing diamonds with slightly lower clarity to still look stunning.

Can inclusions weaken a diamond?

Yes, severe inclusions in I-grade diamonds can affect durability, but most higher-grade stones remain strong and durable. Properly cut and set diamonds with minor inclusions are safe for everyday wear and maintain their brilliance over time.

Back to blog